How to fix the parole system


SCOTT NEWARD / Guest Columnist

Troy Media

Canadians have rightly been gripped by the plight of the Hebert family of Sparwood, B.C. whose three-year old son was abducted, with Randall Hopley, a convicted sex offender and career criminal, the prime suspect.

While Kienan Hebert has thankfully been returned home safely, this incident, along with other high-profile crimes committed by repeat offenders, illustrates clear deficiencies in the justice system that require immediate attention.

Dealing effectively with crime is an inherently complex issue, in part because of the number of independent institutions within the justice system, such as the police, prosecution, courts, corrections and parole boards, all of which need to co-ordinate their efforts to support public safety.

Small number commit most crimes

These institutions already treat dissimilar individuals, such as young offenders, in different ways. For example, there is a concerted effort to use proactive steps to try to prevent young people from getting involved in crime and, even when they do, we sensibly use more lenient measures to provide alternatives and life structure so that young people make better choices and stop committing crime. If early intervention and youth-specific strategies can get young offenders back on the path to productive, law-abiding lives, without burdening the taxpayer with the financial and social costs of incarcerating them, all Canadians will be better for it.

But one of the grim realities confronting our justice system is that a disproportionately large volume of crime is committed by a disproportionately small number of repeat offenders. The justice system has tools to deal with these sorts of individuals, including long-term imprisonment where, at best, correctional programming can build positive behavioural changes and, at worst, the simple expedient of incarceration eliminates their criminal potential for that time in custody. The length of imprisonment for most crimes is determined by a sliding scale that considers both the severity of the crime and the criminal’s unique characteristics, including criminal history.

Unfortunately, the reality of the prevalence of repeat offenders in crime is not reflected in our current parole eligibility laws. Specifically, offenders who have repeatedly committed crimes while on parole are still eligible for parole at the same time as a first offender. This disjointed, “one-size-fits-all” approach undermines the collective goal of increased public safety through reduced crime, especially when it comes to repeat offenders.

The Harper government has made significant improvements to support the integrity of the corrections and parole system by permitting longer parole ineligibility for multiple murderers, eliminating advanced early release for murderers and removing parole eligibility for those who have completed only one-sixth of a court-imposed sentence.

Hopefully, with a majority mandate and an unmistakable commitment to public safety, the government will now address repeat-offender parole reform. The recommendations offered here would be a good start.

First, convert statutory release into earned parole. Currently, offenders have a presumptive right of release (with rare exceptions) after not more than two-thirds of their sentence no matter how often they broke the law or breached parole. Parole must be a privilege to be earned, not a right to be demanded on a predetermined schedule.

Second, legislate escalating future parole ineligibility consequences for people who commit crimes while on parole.

Third, breaching parole conditions should itself be a crime that Correctional Services of Canada (CSC) and the Parole Board of Canada (PBC) are required to take into account in making their decisions.

Fourth, the CSC and PBC should be required by law to consider the availability of post-sentence supervision for high-risk offenders in making their decisions.

Fifth, the parole board should be authorized to order electronic monitoring of high-risk parolees.

Sixth, a public analysis of correctional programs to measure re-offending impact should be undertaken with resources re-allocated to more effective programs.

Seventh, the government’s platform in the last election included an attempt to create a drug-free environment in prisons. This is a huge challenge, but would pay enormous dividends. Though our expectations for success must be realistic, it should still be pursued.

Eighth, the Immigration Refugee Protection Act and the International Transfer of Offenders Act should be amended so as to expedite the removal of non-citizen criminals convicted of crimes in Canada.

Implementing these eight recommendations would yield immediate, meaningful, and real public safety dividends for our country and its citizens.

Scott Newark is a former Crown prosecutor in the Wetaskiwin judicial district and author of several studies on crime.

Just Posted

UPDATED: Boys and Girls Club looking for new home in Rimbey

The organization has lost their dedicated space at the Peter Lougheed Community Centre

Rimbey RCMP ask people to watch for ‘funny money’

RCMP says local businesses have received counterfeit currency in recent transactions

NDP Leader Rachel Notley stops in Red Deer on campaign trail

Notley promises hospital expansion, cath lab, pipelines and energy industry expansion

PHOTOS: Rimbey Library packed during petting zoo

Rimbey kids had a great time at the Zoo 2 U Petting Zoo

Rimbey Museum to display heritage quilts

The quilts were found recently at the Rimbey Hospital and Care Centre

Truck driver in fatal Broncos crash sentenced to eight years

Judge Inez Cardinal told court in Melfort, Sask., that Sidhu’s remorse and guilty plea were mitigating factors

Fierce feline spotted as ‘aggressor’ in face off with coyote in B.C. backyard

North Vancouver resident Norm Lee captures orange cat versus coyote in backyard showdown

Wilson-Raybould to reveal more details, documents on SNC-Lavalin affair

Former attorney general has written to the House of Commons justice committee

Anti-discrimination group wants to map offenders with cross-Canada hate atlas

Morgane Oger Foundation issues call for volunteers to help build Canadian Atlas of Populist Extremism

GM announces jobs, electric vehicle after Trump criticism

The company says it will spend $300 million at its plant in Orion Township

Trucker who caused Broncos crash likely to be deported: lawyer

The Crown has asked that Sidhu serve 10 years in prison

China chemical plant blast kills 47, injures hundreds more

This is one of China’s worst industrial accidents in recent years

Montreal priest stabbed while celebrating morning mass

The incident happened Friday morning at Montreal’s St. Joseph’s Oratory

Women of Excellence Awards introduces ‘Women of Excellence in Construction’

Gala will take place June 19th at the Sheraton Red Deer

Most Read